Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Clinical Cardiology in South East Asia: Indonesian Lessons from the Present towards Improvement Cover

Clinical Cardiology in South East Asia: Indonesian Lessons from the Present towards Improvement

Open Access
|Sep 2022

Figures & Tables

Image 1

Indonesia in South-East Asia Region (SEAR), with cardiac centers across the archipelago.

Image 2

Distribution of cardiologists in Indonesia.

Table 1

Key problems of cardiovascular care in Indonesia, based on our observation.

HEALTHCARE SYSTEM
  • - Low access to care

  • - Healthcare facilities: inequality and distance (problems with transportation)

  • - Unavailable or unaffordable CVD services in primary care

  • - Lack of collaboration between hospitals and primary care doctors

  • - Utilization of ambulance is underused, especially in rural areas

  • - Immature health insurance coverage, or unaffordable health insurance

  • - Lack of surveillance and disease monitoring in the population

  • - Primary care has insufficient capacity to diagnose, monitor, and manage CVD burden, including hypertension and diabetes

HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS
  • - Limited availability of health personnel, especially in remote areas

  • - Lack of standardization among healthcare providers and experts in cardiology practice

  • - Authority in decision-making, ignoring the guideline standards

  • - Poor management of after-discharge care

PATIENTS
  • - Low awareness of CVD symptoms and risk factors

  • - Financial problems: high out-of-pocket expenditure or expensive cost of essential treatments, such as medicines for hypertension, diabetes, and cholesterol

  • - Low adherence to medications for primary and secondary prevention

  • - Low level of education of the patients and family, in the context of adherence to guideline recommendations

Table 2

Proposed conceptual framework for improving the quality of cardiovascular care in Indonesia (based on the local needs and settings).

HEALTHCARE SYSTEM
  • - Reduce delay in hospital admission, especially for patients with acute CVD

  • - Reduce administrative and insurance barriers in the hospital

  • - Accessible and affordable cardiovascular care at Puskesmas (primary care centers), such as ambulatory ECG, standardized laboratory checks

  • - Improve access to revascularization services

  • - Implementing telemedicine or mobile-health program through SMS/phone calls to improve lifestyle and adherence to after-discharge medications

  • - Tele-ECG monitoring and consulting at the primary care level

  • - Reliable patient registries should be available in a computerized format

  • - Improve data collection for healthcare utilization (i.e. population surveillance, CVD registry, death registry, etc)

  • - Preventive strategies: optimizing health and nutrition in pregnant women (including vaccination prior to or during pregnancy and adequate treatment for maternal high blood pressure)

    • ▪ Lifestyle improvement: reduce consumption of fatty or deep-fried food, sugar, salty or MSG-contained, and fast food; promote active lifestyle; smoking cessation

    • ▪ Adequate treatment for hypertension and diabetes: accessible care and diagnostic tools and essential medicines at primary level

HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS
  • - Timely and standardized initial management for acute CVD

  • - Implement clinical practice guidelines and improve adherence to the guideline recommendations

  • - Improve hospital discharge planning and transition to chronic care

  • - Update knowledge and skills

PATIENTS
  • - Improve awareness of acute CVD symptoms

  • - Improve home monitoring and awareness of CVD risk factors

  • - Optimizing patients’ adherence and engagement with long-term medications

  • - Improve lifestyle

Image 3

Routine healthcare services and implementation of tele-ECG program in a primary care center (Puskesmas) in Indonesia.

Image 4

Primary care nurse performing patient follow-up (for cohort research) through home visit.

Table 3

Key challenges of conducting clinical/hospital-based research in low-to-middle-income settings in Indonesia (learning from our experience).

SYSTEM/ENVIRONMENT
  • - Lack or unavailable patient registries/computerized database

  • - Limited and unreliable paper-based medical records

  • - Limited or unavailable population surveillance

  • - Unavailable/limited death registry

  • - Inadequate research infrastructures: research devices/tools should be shared with routine services in the hospital

  • - Less support from the hospital environment (e.g. administrative barriers)

  • - Lack of supportive facilities: poor internet connection, limited access to knowledge resources (e.g. international journals)

RESEARCHERS (ACADEMICIAN AND CLINICIAN)
  • - Limited dedicated time for research, particularly if the investigators are clinicians

  • - Lack of peer supports

  • - High-cost expenditures (e.g. hiring research assistant, laboratory expenses, rewards to patients/participants, high publication costs)

  • - Research community is less familiar with the scientific language of English

  • - Low ‘research and writing’ culture

PATIENTS
  • - Negative attitude towards research: low participation rate, patients/family members’ mistrust, and negative prejudice, rejection for follow-up

  • - High rate of lost-to-follow-up, in particular for those from rural areas

  • - Informed consent issues: difficulty in getting approval from patients and family members (especially if intervention is needed), verbal informed consent for illiterates

  • - Low education and social values are strong influencers (more comprehensive communications are needed for illiterates/low-educated participants)

  • - Language barriers: some patients/participants only use their local/traditional language, not Bahasa Indonesia

LMICs: Low- and middle-income countries
CVD: Cardiovascular disease
WHO: World Health Organization
CAD: Coronary Artery Disease
HICs: High-income countries
SEAR: South-East Asia Region
CI: Confidence Interval
DALYs: Disability-adjusted life-years
GBD: Global Burden of Disease
RHD: Rheumatic Heart Disease
REMEDY: Global Rheumatic Heart Disease Registry
CHDs: Congenital Heart Defects
COHARD-PH: COngenital HeARt Disease in Adult and Pulmonary Hypertension
NCDs: Noncommunicable diseases
CABG: Coronary Artery bypass Graft
PCI: Percutaneous Coronary Intervention
CHF: Congestive Heart Failure
PURE: Prospective Urban and Rural Epidemiology
MONICA: MONItoring of Trends and Determinants of CArdiovascular Disease
ECG: Electrocardiography
GPs: General Practitioners
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/gh.1133 | Journal eISSN: 2211-8179
Language: English
Submitted on: Jan 4, 2022
Accepted on: Jun 24, 2022
Published on: Sep 13, 2022
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2022 Andriany Qanitha, Nurul Qalby, Muzakkir Amir, Cuno S. P. M. Uiterwaal, Jose P. S. Henriques, Bastianus A. J. M. de Mol, Idar Mappangara, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.