Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Lessons Learnt from HIV and Noncommunicable Disease Healthcare Integration in Sub-Saharan Africa Cover

Lessons Learnt from HIV and Noncommunicable Disease Healthcare Integration in Sub-Saharan Africa

Open Access
|Nov 2024

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Overview of all discussed cases.

STUDYCOUNTRYPERIODSERVICESNCD CONDITIONSFACILITATORSBARRIERS
Model 1: NCD care integrated into existing HIV care
AMPATH (9, 45, 46)Kenya2010–2013
  • – Screening at home, local health facilities and hospitals

  • – Referral of patient

  • – Training of CHW

Diabetes Hypertension
  • – Improved BP

  • – Reduced glucose levels

  • – None reported

Integrated Chronic Diseases Management (ICDM) model (42, 43, 44)South AfricaSince 2011
  • – Reorganization of facilities

  • – Training of healthcare staff

  • – Providing clinical guidelines

  • – CHW for adherence support and screening

  • – Strengthened supply chains

Asthma
COPD
Diabetes
Epilepsy
Hypertension
Mental health
  • – Increased BP control

  • – Increased HIV control

  • – Inadequate adaption of care model by staff

  • – Underresourced facilities

  • – Lack of privacy

  • – Lack of patient education

Integrated Chronic Care Clinics (IC3)(12, 36)Malawi2014–2015
  • – Screening in the clinic

  • – Patient education

  • – Free supply of medication

  • – Referral of patients

  • – CHW for adherence and social support

  • – Training existing staff, including reducing high turnover rates

  • – Patient masterfile

Asthma
Diabetes
Epilepsy
Hypertension
Mental health
  • – Increased NCD service accessibility

  • – Improved clinical outcomes and retention rates

  • – Stable HIV control

  • – None reported

TASSH intervention (30, 39)NigeriaSince 2014
  • – Screening at primary health centres

  • – Lifestyle counselling

  • – Referral of patients

  • – Taskshifting by nurses

Hypertension
  • – Reduced BP

  • – Increased HT control

  • – Reduced HIV stigma

  • – Lack of medication

  • – Insufficient referral system

  • – Lack of policies

HIV Clinic at Zomba Central Hospital (16, 25)Malawi2016–2017
  • – Taskshifting by existing staff

  • – Patient counselling

  • – Screening at hospital

  • – Using expert clients for data collection

  • – Provision of medication

  • – Electronic medical patient file

Diabetes
Hypertension
  • – Saving time for patient and provider

  • – Improving awareness among patients

  • – Increased workload

  • – Shortages of tools

NAMPROPA (QIC) (41)Namibia2016–2018
  • – NCD screening at HIV facilities

  • – Training of nurses for counselling and referrals

  • – Health volunteers for data collection

Hypertension
  • – Increased number of NCD cases

  • – Low linkage to care rate

SEARCH Study (22, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 66)Uganda
Kenya
2018–2020
  • – Health campaigns in communities, offering screening and treatment.

  • – Training existing healthcare staff

  • – Providing a pleasant clinical environment

  • – Patient education

Hypertension
  • – Increased HT control

  • – Stable HIV control

  • – Lower mortality

  • – Medication stockouts

Mulago clinic (37, 38)Uganda2019–2020
  • – Routine screening in clinic/hospital

  • – Delivery of care

  • – Patient education

  • – Taskshifting by nurses

  • – Free supply of medication

Hypertension
  • – Increased HT control

  • – Stable HIV control

  • – Lack of medication

  • – Lack of policies

  • – Lack of patient documentation

Model 2: HIV care integrated into NCD care
CIDRZ programme (9)Zambia2008–2011
  • – HIV testing and counselling at primary healthcare facilities

  • – Enrolment in same facility

Outpatient clinic
  • – Increased number of HIV case findings

  • – Increased efficiency of space, resources and staff time

  • – Decreased HIV stigma

  • – None reported.

Government Reproductive Child Health Clinics (9)Tanzania2010–2013
  • – HIV screening for cervical cancer patients

  • – Referral of patients

Cervical cancer
  • – None reported.

  • – Lack of enough equipment

Model 3: Simultaneous implementation of NCD and HIV care
Collaborative programme (9)Uganda2011
  • – Screening in communities

  • – Referral of patients

  • – Patient education

  • – Arrangement of transportation

Diabetes
Hypertension
  • – Increased number of HIV and NCD case findings

  • – Low linkage to care rate

Ministry of Health (9)Lesotho2011
  • – Screening in communities

  • – Referral of patients

Diabetes
Hypertension
  • – None reported.

  • – Low linkage to care rate

Homebased testing (Linkages Study) (23, 28, 51)South Africa2012–2013
  • – Screening at home

  • – Health counselling

  • – Linkage to care nearby

  • – Training of CHW

  • – NCD risk factor screening

Cholesterol
Diabetes
Hypertension
Mental health
  • – Increased number of HIV and NCD case findings

  • – None reported

MOCCA (INTEAFRICA) (10, 11, 19, 48, 49, 50, 65)Tanzania Uganda2018–2020
  • – Screening and treatment at clinics

  • – Training of existing staff

  • – Health counselling

Diabetes
Hypertension
  • – Improved retention rates

  • – Stable HIV control

  • – Acceptability by patients and providers

  • – Long waiting time

  • – Lack of medication

  • – Fear of HIV stigma

[i] Includes a summary of the main services provided by the programme, the years of performance and a summary of the main findings per case. BP = blood pressure; COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; CWH = community health worker; HIV = human immunodeficiency virus; HT = hypertension; NCD = non-communicable disease.

Figure 1

Lessons learnt from HIV and noncommunicable disease healthcare integration in sub-Saharan Africa. Graphical overview of the narrative review with the main findings. Several facilitators and barriers, combined with the perspective of providers, patients, and policymakers resulted in the recommendation for the development of future healthcare integration programmes in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). The goal of successful integrated health is to detect novel cases and improve patient adherence to reduce the NCD burden and overall health in SSA. HIV = human immunodeficiency virus; NCD = noncommunicable disease.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/gh.1370 | Journal eISSN: 2211-8179
Language: English
Submitted on: Feb 29, 2024
Accepted on: Oct 27, 2024
Published on: Nov 12, 2024
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2024 Jessica S. van der Mannen, Martin Heine, Samanta T. Lalla-Edward, Dike B. Ojji, Ana O. Mocumbi, Kerstin Klipstein-Grobusch, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.