Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Italian Hospital Teachers’ Perceptions of Technological and Methodological Innovations after the COVID-19 Pandemic Cover

Italian Hospital Teachers’ Perceptions of Technological and Methodological Innovations after the COVID-19 Pandemic

Open Access
|Apr 2023

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Age Distribution (Percentages).

AGED 19–29AGED 30–39AGED 40–49AGED OVER 50
Female1%7%18%74%
Male6%30%24%40%
Table 2

Frequency of Employing the Various Teaching Modes (Percentages).

NEVERFOR A FEW MONTHSFOR ABOUT HALF OF THE SCHOOL YEARMOST OF THE TIMEALWAYS
Face-to-face10.3%13.6%15.6%25.5%35%
Distance41.2%28.4%9.9%11.5%9.1%
Table 3

Frequency of Teaching Methods Adopted in Face-to-Face Mode (Percentages).

NEVERRARELYSOMETIMESOFTENALWAYS
Lectures4.4%2%12.3%33%48.3%
Group work51.2%20.7%13.8%9.9%4.4%
Brainstorming26.1%10.3%31%22.2%10.3%
Drill & practice21.2%3.9%25.1%33%16.7%
Project-based learning23.2%19.7%29.6%22.2%5.4%
Gamification31.5%17.7%31%15.3%4.4%
Playful activities13.8%14.8%22.2%0%49.3%
Teaching essential knowledge6.4%3.9%26.1%46.3%17.2%
Other strategies56.4%5.4%21.3%14.9%2%
Table 4

Frequency of Teaching Methods Adopted in Distance Mode (Percentages).

NEVERRARELYSOMETIMESOFTENALWAYS
Lectures8.4%7.6%10.7%0%73.3%
Group work71,8%12.2%7.6%0%8.4%
Brainstorming25.2%13%31.3%20.6%9.9%
Drill & practice20.6%6.1%25.2%33.6%14.5%
Project-based learning37.4%16%26%16%4.6%
Gamification45.8%10.7%26.7%14.5%2.3%
Playful activities33.64%12.2%22.9%24.4%6.9%
Teaching essential knowledge7.6%4.65%28.2%38.9%20.6%
Table 5

Changes in Frequency of Use of Different Devices (Percentages).

DECREASEDSTABLEINCREASEDNO DATA
PC/laptop2.7%24.4%56.4%16.4%
Tablet3.6%31.1%40.9%24.4%
Smartphone0.9%30.4%53.1%15.6%
Table 6

Resources Used for Carrying out Face-to-Face Lessons (Percentages).

USEDNOT USED
One or more common productivity applications (word processing, spreadsheets, presentations, etc.)73.1%26.9%
Shared online workspaces (Google Drive, Dropbox, etc.)66.5%33.5%
Collaborative writing applications (Wiki, Google Docs, Book creator, etc.)43.7%56.3%
Educational robotics and coding applications (Bee bot, Ozobot, Scratch, etc.)17.9%82.1%
Other cloud applications (i.e., Padlet, Kahoot, etc.)40.4%59.6%
Online educational resources83.8%16.2%
Table 7

Changes in the Use of Resources (Percentages).

DECREASEDSTABLEINCREASEDNO DATA
One or more common productivity applications (word processing, spreadsheets, presentations, etc.)5%35.8%37.8%21.4%
Shared online workspaces (Google Drive, Dropbox, etc.)2%26.3%49.8%21.9%
Collaborative writing applications (Wiki, Google Docs, Book creator, etc.)1%32.3%31.4%35.3%
Educational robotics and coding applications (Bee bot, Ozobot, Scratch, etc.)4%35.7%7.5%52.8%
Other cloud applications (i.e., Padlet, Kahoot, etc.)2.5%30%28%39.5%
Online educational resources1.5%35.86%47.3%15.4%
Table 8

Resources Used for Carrying out Distance Lessons (Percentages).

NEVERRARELYSOMETIMESOFTENALWAYS
Electronic school roll36.9%3.1%1.5%3.8%54.6%
Videoconference systems (Skype, Zoom)12.3%4.6%10.8%15.4%56.9%
Instant messaging (WhatsApp, Telegram, etc.)10.8%3.1%11.5%40.8%33.8%
Platforms for remote education (Moodle, Classroom, etc.)30.8%8.5%19.2%14.6%26.9%
Publishers’ applications53.1%9.2%12.3%16.2%9.2%
Shared online workspaces (Google Drive, Dropbox, etc.)27.7%7.7%20.8%26.9%16.9%
Collaborative writing applications51.5%13.8%13.1%14.65%6.97%
Other cloud applications (Padlet, Kahoot, etc.)54.65%9.2%17.78%13.1%5.4%
Online educational resources6.2%6.9%32.3%42.3%12.3%
Table 9

Themes, Codes, Descriptions, and Examples Emerging from the Questionnaire’s Open-Ended Questions.

THEMESCODESDESCRIPTIONSEXAMPLES
Q1: Positive Aspects
TechnologiesLearning new technological skillsTeachers recognizd the positive effect of improving their skills in the use of technology“The spread of the pandemic, however, forced us to specialize more in the educational and technological tools available to us.”
Teaching innovationBlended teachingTeachers recognized the positive effect of blended instruction on hospitalized students’ learning path“One significant benefit was continuity of the personal learning paths started in the hospital, which, with integrated digital didactic, could continue throughout the periods of students’ precautionary isolation and also during brief hospital discharges.”
Need to plan educational activitiesTeachers reported that they had improved their planning of educational activities“We learned how to plan our synchronous and asynchronous lessons more efficiently.”
Use of new teaching methodologiesTeachers reported that they had tested new teaching methodologies in response to the emergency condition“Increased creativity in the use of different and innovative teaching tools, especially digital-based ones.”
Distance LearningTeacher resourceTeachers recognized that distance learning can be a resource in their practice“The [forced] discovery of distance learning as a viable resource.”
Student resourceTeachers reported that distance learning had improved the social well-being of hospitalized students“Distance learning made it possible for hospitalized children to feel like peers who are unable to be present in the classroom.”
Q2: Negative Aspects
Teaching limitationsInability to perform group activitiesTeachers reported that they had not been able to implement group teaching activities“Inability to implement group activities with other hospitalized students.”
Inability to use some traditional educational toolsTeachers reported that they were unable to use some traditional teaching tools (e.g., Lego, books, games)“Inability to quickly share materials such as pencils and paper.”
Distance LearningInternet connection problemsTeachers reported that Internet connection problems in the hospital had been a problem for distance learning“Internet connection failures throughout the hospital.”
Organizational issuesTeachers reported problems in planning distance education in the hospital school setting“Difficulties in organizing distance learning lessons with students admitted for [only] a few days.”
Distance learning difficulties related to school subject areaTeachers experienced more difficulties in science subjects than humanities during distance learning lessons“Difficulties were more likely to occur in science subjects. In humanities subjects. there were no major problems.”
Distance learning difficulties with foreign studentsTeachers noted more language difficulties when interacting with foreign students during distance learning“It was extremely difficult (also) to get through to foreign students. For them, the main trouble was understanding instructions without body language support.”
Distance learning is less stimulatingTeachers reported that distance learning reduced their capacity to convey passion as they used to do during face-to-face activities“The side effect of distance learning is, because of the distance, teachers are not able to convey the same passion as they normally do during face-to-face activities. Distance learning is surely less successful in stimulating students’ minds.”
Q3: Issues to be improved
Distance LearningImproving distance learning implementationTeachers considered the possibility of improving distance learning teaching with technology solutions“Distance learning effectiveness could be improved using technology solutions so as to stimulate and involve the pupil even at a distance.”
Distance learning as mediation with schools of originTeachers considered distance learning as a solution for increasing connections and mediation with mainstream schools“Interaction with schools also could be increased through distance learning.”
TechnologyImproving technology resourcesTeachers expressed the need to increase the technological resources available in hospitals dedicated to educational purposes“There is certainly a need to increase the multimedia tools available to teachers and improve Wi-Fi connections in the wards.”
Improving hospitals’ Wi-Fi connectionTeachers expressed the need to improve Wi-Fi connection to ensure a good standard of distance learning“Internet connection troubles throughout the hospital. The only alternative is using the connection of students’ own devices.”
Adopting digital school rollTeachers expressed the need to enhance the digital school roll system so it is as easy to use as the one adopted in mainstream schools“The hospital school roll is a bit intricate; could be more user-friendly, more similar to digital school records adopted in mainstream schools.”
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/cie.65 | Journal eISSN: 2631-9179
Language: English
Submitted on: Nov 11, 2022
Accepted on: Feb 21, 2023
Published on: Apr 14, 2023
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2023 Francesca Maria Dagnino, Vincenza Benigno, Edoardo Dalla Mutta, Chiara Fante, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.